25 November 2015
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
PARLIAMENTARY AD HOC COMMITTEE IGNORES KING ZWELITHINI’S HATE SPEECH
This week, the Parliamentary Ad hoc Committee on Probing Violence against Foreign Nationals released its report on its investigations into the xenophobic attacks that occurred in April and May 2015. Sonke Gender Justice (Sonke) and Lawyers for Human Rights (LHR) note the report with disappointment due to the lack of adequate analysis on xenophobia and especially King Zwelithini’s role in catalyzing the attacks.
The report and its findings
The report fails to make clear findings on the nature and extent of xenophobia in South Africa and instead seems to attribute xenophobia to “criminals” and “drug addicts”. The report states:
“The main causes of the violent attacks were criminal actions that started with stealing of goods from foreign owned spaza shops by South African criminals who are often drug addicts. The spaza shop owners would react by shooting at those who steal from their spaza shops using unregistered firearms rather than reporting to the police.”
Xenophobia is driven by a pre-existing prejudice towards a person or people based on their nationality or social origin. While South Africans were also affected and harmed in the 2008 and 2015 xenophobic attacks, the vast majority of cases of violence and harm were specifically directed towards foreign migrants by South Africans. The Committee missed an important opportunity to denounce the xenophobia of many South Africans, and speak out strongly against violence, prejudice and discrimination.
King Zwelithini and his address in Pongola
On 20 March 2015, King Goodwill Zwelithini addressed a large crowd of people at a ‘moral regeneration’ event in Pongola. He made a number of offensive remarks about foreign migrants, such as
- “The time for vision has come. I request our South African government to help us. Let us get our house in order and clean our land of lice [referring to foreigners]. […]”
- “We need to remove all itching bedbugs and lay them bare in the sun, they will choose to hide because of the heat of the sun.”
- “We request that all foreigners should take their baggage and be sent back. […]”
- “We have very good relationships with some African countries, but we should not have the type of relationships that will turn us into weaklings such that we end being said to be holier than others in Africa. Let us not be holy because they have their laws, we should also have our own laws. The police are the backbone of the safety of the country, they are the answer to a community living in fear of crime. The police are the first to hear about problems, because they work within the communities. That is why I say we must deal with our lice […]”
The audio file of the King’s fifty minute speech is available on the Sonke website.
Sonke and LHR believe that this speech amounts to hate speech as defined by Promotion of Equality and Prevention of Unfair Discrimination Act (the Equality Act).
Sonke presented a written submission to the ad hoc committee in which they provided the King’s full speech. Sonke also provided evidence of how the King expressed strong anti-foreign national sentiment, and attributed a range of negative and harmful qualities to cross-border migrants that appeared to have elicited strong popular appeal among the King’s supporters. They asked that the Ad Hoc committee hold the King accountable for his words, apologises, as well as, request the King to initiate and actively participate in community dialogues between South Africans and foreign migrants with the aim of building stronger and more cohesive communities.
In its report, the Ad Hoc Committee provides no analysis or findings on the King’s Pongola speech.
It is essential that the King be held accountable for his hate speech. We believe that the Ad Hoc Committee has ignored the impact of the King’s anti-foreigner sentiments and the role it had played in the xenophobic attacks.
We are aware that the South African Human Right Commission has received a number of complaints about hate speech by the King, and is still to release its findings. Our attempts last week to obtain a progress update by the Commission were unsuccessful.
Sonke and LHR, therefore call on the SAHRC to urgently release its report on xenophobia and to hold King Zwelithini accountable for his words.
The Ad Hoc Committee’s report is available at http://pmg-assets.s3-website-eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/151119Final_Report.pdf
The audio files, transcript and translation of the King’s speech are available at http://www.genderjustice.org.za/policy-development-advocacy/challenging-xenophobia-keeping-leaders-accountable-inciting-hate
Sonke Gender Justice
Sonke Gender Justice
(o) 021 423 7088
(c) 082 858 9927
Lawyers for Human Rights